Skip to content
SpinProverse

Parents Who Capture Their Children Crying for Engagement Ought to Reflect at Themselves

A specific melody has been stuck in my mind the past period, and no, it isn't from Taylor Swift's latest album. It is sung by a considerably more sophisticated composer: a children's entertainer. The piece is called Big Feelings and its lyrics state: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Rise of Strong Emotions Online

Because of the popularity for mindful parenting, the notion of “big feelings” has transformed into profitable on the web, and generally I welcome that. Being a parent, powerful emotions are hard to escape: one is having them, the small child in your home is feeling them and, in one of the most significant changes for us as a species, so are numerous other children on your social media feed.

Indeed, footage of toddlers and children sobbing is so widespread on various platforms that numerous parents don't even question it. I avoid TikTok and my Instagram suggestions is mainly fixated on soup and witchcraft, but when a friend told me that she considered the trend concerning, not to mention unethical, I viewed some of the recordings myself.

What I Found: Youngsters at Their Most Vulnerable

What I found was clip after clip of children at their most vulnerable. Crying, yelling, shrieking, and sometimes acting out. I have naturally been present to these situations in my own home, but watching a different child going through it feels excruciatingly uncomfortable, especially when that child is without reassurance by their own parent. Least forgivable is a genre of video in which parents expose their children to medical procedures while their little one sobs and yells right into the recording. It is important to mention that the majority of the videos are not as extreme, and yet there is nonetheless something disturbing about them all.

When Strong Emotions Aren't Upsetting

Certainly, “big feelings” are not always completely traumatic. When your child is lying on the ground distraught at the discovery that cake isn't infinite it can be hard to keep a straight face. Many of us have been told tales of notably memorable meltdowns of our own. My own included shouting “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the foyer of the Institute of Contemporary Arts in central London. Playfully teasing your child about a time they had a tantrum, or chuckling over it with your spouse once they have fallen asleep, is understandable. Recording a child in a situation of vulnerability and posting it to the internet for all to see without permission is a different matter entirely.

Unpleasant Trends and Humiliation

Furthermore you have the phenomena that are simply disturbing, such as one that involved startling babies to stop crying by tossing a slice of cheese at their faces, or breaking an egg on them. Such content appears aimed at humiliating children. In a report for the a newspaper, a writer commented: “The eeriest part of these videos [is that] the parents are hardly interacting with their kids. Instead they are responding to a online representation of their children that they are sharing online. And they are enjoying their power over that image.”

The Justification of Teachability

A number of video creators who would despise this sort of content. They claim that they are capturing their children at their most exposed not to mock them, but because they are attempting to develop educational instances – “just look at how peacefully and effectively I was able to defuse this child’s outburst using these techniques”. Some even aim to stave off certain criticism. “This video is posted to inform and promote knowledge – not for approval or views”, a particular clip, shared by an account managed by a medical professional, reportedly reads. The statement that ensues is some of the most self-praising rubbish I have encountered on the web. “If you don’t live the life, avoid judging the moment.”

An Inquiry of Responsibility

How about you don’t post the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I do judge these people. My perception, when I watch a video of a small child in turmoil, whether their parent is performing comfort or not, is a dereliction of duty – the obligation to be engaged for your child. And I ponder what signal it communicates, when when your child starts expressing a “big feeling”, you reach for your device. What message does that send to your young one about their wholly natural emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, supposedly.

Reflections on Modern Upbringing

When my spouse and I commence visiting schools for our son, it’s challenging not to think about how strategies to parenting have evolved since we were children. There is an enhanced understanding of the fact that “big feelings” are normal for small children. These days a lot of adults aim to acknowledge those emotions and offer children a secure environment in which to share their feelings. However despite what the modern parenting experts state, I do not think you can really offer a safe space for your child if you are capturing their moments of weakness and invading their confidentiality and integrity in the act. To be frank, I cannot see these people have a lot to instruct any of us about parenting.

A Final Question

A few people who will see that as radical, who would recoil from the fact that in certain respects I’d rather put a piece of cheese on my son's face for a laugh than use his suffering as a educational instance for clicks. But to them I would say this: if “all behavior is message”, what, precisely, are these adults trying to say?

By

Robin Moore

A theoretical physicist and science writer passionate about making complex concepts accessible to all.

SpinProverse

Type to search articles.